Expert article
Edit 14 March 2021
by Evangelos Mitsakis, UIA Expert

TMaaS web article No 3 - TMaaS Replicator City program Part 2: lessons learnt

TMaaS web article No 3 - TMaaS Replicator City program Part 2: lessons learnt

The TMaaS Replicator City program is an important part of the TMaaS project. Its ambitious aim is to increase the number of cities that use the TMaaS solutions and to provide assistance to the external interested cities in doing so. As the TMaaS project and the Replicator program come to an end, some useful conclusions and lessons learnt have been drawn, which are discussed in this web-article of the TMaaS project. The lessons learnt are mostly targeted towards future similar programs and cities or other entities that may plan and execute them, in order to transfer innovative solutions developed within projects to cities or related entities outside the project partnership.

 

Technical challenges:

It has been shown within the TMaaS Replicator City program that replication cities have different context and different problems to solve, different existing infrastructures, different data sources as well as different languages. It is thus important to account for these differences to the extent possible at the initial design stage of the solution, in order to be able to cover requirements and use cases that may differentiate from the ones that are associated with the core participating cities. Thus, the timing of the execution of the Replicator program within the project itself plays a significant role, as such requirements can probably be known earlier on, when time allows to account for them sufficiently at technical level. A plug-and-play solution is difficult to implement, due to the diversity of the above-mentioned parameters. Use of standard formats is desirable, however the practical absence of standards’ implementation poses a barrier that requires case-by-case solutions.

 

Level of interest and commitment:

It has been proven difficult to attract the interest of cities outside of Europe, as most existing communication practices and related networks have a clear focus within Europe itself. Another issue to be considered is the need to be able to reach out to the right people at city authorities, as traffic management in itself is associated with both technical aspects as well as with policy aspects for cities. Understanding the benefits of adapting innovative solutions and committing to allocating resources and time in their implementation requires a balance of technical and political support, thus the involvement of several city authority departments and levels of decision making.

 

Application procedure:

TMaaS had adopted a simple, not simplified, application procedure, in order to maximize the chances of cities applying to the Replicator program. An important lesson learnt is that all procedures should be electronic, to avoid time needed for submission of paper documents. Also important is to clearly define the terms and conditions for the use of the project’s solutions by Replicator cities after the end of the project, to ensure that expectations for both sides are at the right level.

 

Selection procedure:

The TMaaS selection procedure for the Replicator program has been faced with drop-out of applications, for reasons that go beyond the project’s scope or interests (e.g. local elections and changes in cities’ administrations). However, it has become clear that a short period between application and selection would reduce the risk of such drop-outs. Another lesson learnt is that a step-wise inclusion of replication cities might increase the number of cities with actual interest, as information spread about such activities to cities may take more time, than that provided between the Open Call announcement and the application submission date. Finally, as technical and non-technical risks remain significant, it is recommended to keep a balance between innovation and feasibility in such replication activities, in order to reduce risks and pressures at both sides.

Share

Other news from this project

TMaaS web article No 2 - TMaaS Replicator City program Part 1: process and results

TMaaS web article No 2 - TMaaS Replicator City program Part 1: process and results...

TMaaS - Traffic Management as a Service

Urban mobility

Ghent - Belgium

Urban mobility
The TMaaS Project Journal No 4

The TMaaS Project Journal No 4

The present fourth edition of the TMaaS Journal aims to provide interested readers with information concerning the project’s final achievements and re...

TMaaS - Traffic Management as a Service

Urban mobility

Ghent - Belgium

Urban mobility

TMaaS web article No 4 - Interview with Sophie Gillaerts, the TMaaS project coordinator

TMaaS web article No 4 - Interview with Sophie Gillaerts, the TMaaS project coordinator...

TMaaS - Traffic Management as a Service

Urban mobility

Ghent - Belgium

Urban mobility

TMaaS web article No 1 - TMaaS notifications for travellers

TMaaS web article No 1 - TMaaS notifications for travellers...

TMaaS - Traffic Management as a Service

Urban mobility

Ghent - Belgium

Urban mobility

TMaaS web article No 5 - The TMaaS products

TMaaS web article No 5 - The TMaaS products ...

TMaaS - Traffic Management as a Service

Urban mobility

Ghent - Belgium

Urban mobility
TMasS Journal 3: update on Ghent's project

TMasS Journal 3: update on Ghent's project

In the 3rd journal of the TMaaS project, the new UIA expert Evangelos Mitsakis dives into recent developments and major achievements of the project. ...

TMaaS - Traffic Management as a Service

Urban mobility

Ghent - Belgium

tmaas mini documentary

3 years of TMaaS in images

TMaaS launches a short film capturing the stories of the project....

TMaaS - Traffic Management as a Service

Urban mobility

Ghent - Belgium

Urban mobility
tmaas final conf

TMaaS Final conference

Thursday 21 January - the time had finally come for the last TMaaS conference that marked the end of an exciting process that had lasted more than thr...

TMaaS - Traffic Management as a Service

Urban mobility

Ghent - Belgium

Urban mobility
Tmaas pic 1

TMaaS & LINK.Gent from a public transport user's behavior perspective

In his first Zoom-In, UIA TMaaS expert Dr. Evangelos Mitsakis, presents an animated story that highlights the decisions that travelers need to take on...

TMaaS - Traffic Management as a Service

Urban mobility

Ghent - Belgium

Urban mobility
Conference is final agreement of the TMaaS project

Conference is final agreement of the TMaaS project

On 21st January the TMaaS Project will conclude with a final conference entitled “A Story of Innovating Mobility Together”. Given the circumstances, i...

TMaaS - Traffic Management as a Service

Urban mobility

Ghent - Belgium

Urban mobility
Adoption potential survey - what's the market potential for TMaaS solutions?

Adoption potential survey - what's the market potential for TMaaS solutions?

The TMaaS project is coming to an end after a long and exciting process. LINK.Gent, the platform that was designed by the consortium, is now operation...

TMaaS - Traffic Management as a Service

Urban mobility

Ghent - Belgium

Adoption potential survey

Adoption potential survey

The TMaaS project is coming to an end after a long and exciting process. LINK.Gent, the platform that was designed by the consortium, is now operation...

TMaaS - Traffic Management as a Service

Urban mobility

Ghent - Belgium

Mintlab Kevin Sanders

TMaaS recruits Ghentians to participate in user surveys

Users have played a crucial role in the TMaaS project right from the very first day. We involved them closely in the development of the LINK.Gent plat...

TMaaS - Traffic Management as a Service

Urban mobility

Ghent - Belgium

Urban mobility
Meet our new interactive mobility monitoring platform: Link.Gent  webinar for cities Thursday 14th of May

Meet our new interactive mobility monitoring platform: Link.Gent webinar for cities Thursday 14th of May

Link.Gent, the multi-modal traffic monitoring dashboard developed TMaaS, was launched in April. Link.Gent offers professional traffic managers of the ...

TMaaS - Traffic Management as a Service

Urban mobility

Ghent - Belgium

First test phase of the TMaaS traffic dashboard a the Gentse Feesten

First test phase of the TMaaS traffic dashboard a the Gentse Feesten

During the previous edition of the Gentse Feesten a new phase of TMaaS got underway and it was finally possible to test the dashboard. ...

TMaaS - Traffic Management as a Service

Urban mobility

Ghent - Belgium

Major trial run of the virtual traffic system during the Gentse Feesten

Major trial run of the virtual traffic system during the Gentse Feesten

TMaaS, the developer of the digital traffic platform for the City of Ghent, will be carrying out a major trial run of its virtual dashboard during the...

TMaaS - Traffic Management as a Service

Urban mobility

Ghent - Belgium

TMAaS journal

TMaaS Expert Journal: Get an update on what has been happening in the last 6 months

The 2nd TMaaS Journal accompanies the project in its past half year of progress. By giving an account of the main activities and achievements of each ...

TMaaS - Traffic Management as a Service

Urban mobility

Ghent - Belgium

TMaaS mobility dashboard

Designing a mobility dashboard: features and considerations

When designing a mobility dashboard, you’ll to want to design something user-friendly and attractive, but above all you will want to create a tool tha...

TMaaS - Traffic Management as a Service

Urban mobility

Ghent - Belgium

Smart Belgium Award 2018

City of Ghent wins the Belfius Smart Belgium Award 2018 with TMaaS

On Wednesday 24 April in Brussels, the City of Ghent won the Belfius Smart Belgium Award 2018 in in the category ‘Smart Cities with a population of mo...

TMaaS - Traffic Management as a Service

Urban mobility

Ghent - Belgium

Replicator programme TMaaS

A webinar provides clarification about the TMaaS Replicator City Programme

TMaaS recently launched a call to cities worldwide to register for the TMaaS Replicator City Programme. This autumn, three selected cities will have t...

TMaaS - Traffic Management as a Service

Urban mobility

Ghent - Belgium

Ghent TMaaS zoom-in

Wider stakeholder engagement is at the heart of TMaaS

The approach adopted by the Partnership entails reaching out to different stakeholder groups in multiple moments throughout the project....

TMaaS - Traffic Management as a Service

Urban mobility

Ghent - Belgium

TMaS replicator programme

TMaaS launches Open Call for Replicator Cities worldwide

TMaaS launched a call for cities worldwide to submit their applications to join the TMaaS Replicator City Programme. In this programme, which will lau...

TMaaS - Traffic Management as a Service

Urban mobility

Ghent - Belgium

Journal 1

TMaaS UIA Expert Journal – Learn more on how the city of Ghent aims to better manage the urban mobility system

UIA Expert, Sofia Taborda, gives a first look on how the project is being implemented ...

TMaaS - Traffic Management as a Service

Urban mobility

Ghent - Belgium

Civitas award

Ghent receives prestigious award for TMaaS project

Our city has been recognised, alongside eight European towns and cities, for its innovative urban mobility strategy at the 2018 CIVITAS Awards ceremon...

TMaaS - Traffic Management as a Service

Urban mobility

Ghent - Belgium

TMaaS and CitiCAP projects

Ghent-Lahti: a tale of two cities

On May 24th we welcomed a delegation from the Finnish CitiCAP project, which, like TMaaS, focuses on smart city mobility. We had an interesting and u...

TMaaS - Traffic Management as a Service

Urban mobility

Ghent - Belgium

Tmaas

Getting citizens on board: the first TMaaS citizen research project

We recently launched an online call for citizens to participate in the first TMaaS citizen research project that focuses on the mobility behaviour of ...

TMaaS - Traffic Management as a Service

Urban mobility

Ghent - Belgium