UIA Article
Edit 11 March 2021
by UIA Permanent Secretariat

Rethink your monitoring and evaluation practices

screenshot platform
You want to capture the change that your project is bringing at local level? The new monitoring and evaluation platform is now online: browse through and find the most relevant and flexible evaluation approach you need.

On Thursday 11 March, around 200 participants from cities, universities, research centres and private organisations explored the platform gathering the final results of the UIA monitoring & evaluation study. It was a key milestone of a year-long process.

UIA considers monitoring and evaluation (M&E) one of its operational challenges. Monitoring and evaluation of results is a challenging task and the focus essentially remains on the monitoring of results. However, a number of urban authorities are using the flexibility and availability of financial resources offered by UIA to go a step beyond, by applying different logic models and evaluation approaches.

In 2020, as part of its capitalisation activities, UIA commissioned Ecorys to conduct the ‘Capitalisation activity on good practices for monitoring and evaluation of results in Urban Innovative Actions (UIA) projects’. As well as identifying good M&E practices, the capitalisation activity aimed to explore why and in what way these could be seen as such.

Nine projects offer clear examples of good practice with respect to different monitoring & evaluation techniques: Antwerp CURANT, Athens Curing the Limbo, Aveiro Steam City, Barcelona B-MINCOME, Brussels CALICO, Paris OASIS, Rotterdam BRIDGE, Utrecht U-RLP and Vienna CoRE.

Built on the experiences of the nine above-mentioned projects, the lessons learnt provide findings and examples that can increase effectiveness and efficiency when evaluating projects and interventions. They are divided into 4 pillars:

1. Evaluation governance : people, processes that connect people, resources available for evaluation.

 

“When you’re focused on executing the project, an evaluator can help you to continuously see the bigger picture. And you can only benefit from that.” 

Source: BRIDGE representative

2. Evaluation approachesa conceptual analytical model, not a specific method or techniques. It is a way of structuring and undertaking analysis, but also data collection.

 

“I think that the most important issue about the B-MINCOME project is that really it was a project of evaluation of public policies. It was the aim of the project. It was not a project about innovation itself, but about evaluation of innovation taking several dimensions.”

Source: B-MINCOME representative

3. Data collection methods: a meaningful and effective evaluation of an innovative project requires robust, well-designed data collection. 

 

“If it is possible (…) embed the use of technology. (…) Use the technology, for instance the IoT platform to gather the data, to treat the data, and to make the data available to all decision makers.”

Source: STEAM City representative

4. Horizontal issues:  issues such as  to consider when setting up a project’s evaluation governance, approach and data collection. 

“In the beginning partners were a bit frustrated when we asked them to collaborate in the evaluation process. Each partner had their own indicators and they thought that all we had to do was to add all these indicators together. Changing this into a shared culture takes time.”

Source: Curing the Limbo representative

Explore the platform, adapt the key lessons and experiences to your own needs and share with us your feedback, questions and ideas by joining the online discussion with #uiacapacitybuilding.

Share

Other news from this project

aveiro

Aveiro STEAM City Journal 2: get to know the project latest achievements

In this second Journal, UIA Expert Lucia Scopelliti through the project latest achievements and challenges. ...

AVEIRO STEAM CITY - Urban Network for Upgrading STEAM Skills and Increasing Jobs Added-Value through Digital Transformation in a new economic context

Jobs and skills in the local economy

Aveiro - Portugal

Jobs and skills in the local economy
press conference

Harvard honours Aveiro with an award in the innovation area

The City of Aveiro has been awarded with the Innovation in Community Engagement Award at Harvard University 2020 City Innovation Award....

AVEIRO STEAM CITY - Urban Network for Upgrading STEAM Skills and Increasing Jobs Added-Value through Digital Transformation in a new economic context

Jobs and skills in the local economy

Aveiro - Portugal

Jobs and skills in the local economy
Picture representing people discussing

Aveiro Tech Week

From October 12th to 18th, the city of Aveiro promoted an entire week dedicated to technology, art and culture with three events. TECHDAYS Aveiro, CRI...

AVEIRO STEAM CITY - Urban Network for Upgrading STEAM Skills and Increasing Jobs Added-Value through Digital Transformation in a new economic context

Jobs and skills in the local economy

Aveiro - Portugal

Jobs and skills in the local economy
Smarter Europe
Aveiro labour observatory

AVEIRO’S LABOUR OBSERVATORY: THE POST-GENERATIONAL WORKFORCE LOOKS BEYOND THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC

AVEIRO STEAM CITY - Urban Network for Upgrading STEAM Skills and Increasing Jobs Added-Value through Digital Transformation in a new economic context

Jobs and skills in the local economy

Aveiro - Portugal

IoT

IoT’S POTENTIAL: AVEIRO'S DEVELOPMENTS IN THE AREAS OF MOBILITY, ENVIRONMENT AND ENERGY

Many municipalities all over the world turn to the Internet of Things (IoT) in order to prevent environmental deterioration, mitigate traffic congesti...

AVEIRO STEAM CITY - Urban Network for Upgrading STEAM Skills and Increasing Jobs Added-Value through Digital Transformation in a new economic context

Jobs and skills in the local economy

Aveiro - Portugal

Data management
Digital transition
Digitalisation
Energy Transition
Greener Europe
Jobs and skills in the local economy
Smarter Europe
Aveiro Project

Kick-off Sessions for Aveiro Tech City Challenges

During the last months the City of Aveiro triggered the Aveiro Tech City Challenges using a mixture of on-site and remote resources, promoting a colla...

AVEIRO STEAM CITY - Urban Network for Upgrading STEAM Skills and Increasing Jobs Added-Value through Digital Transformation in a new economic context

Jobs and skills in the local economy

Aveiro - Portugal

Jobs and skills in the local economy
Aveiro Steam City Living Lab

AVEIRO STEAM CITY LIVING LAB, THE CITY-AS-A-PLATFORM

A couple of years ago the Guardian declared the need for cities to become active as Living Labs, as places where designers, scientists, companies and ...

AVEIRO STEAM CITY - Urban Network for Upgrading STEAM Skills and Increasing Jobs Added-Value through Digital Transformation in a new economic context

Jobs and skills in the local economy

Aveiro - Portugal

Connected Europe
Digital transition
Jobs and skills in the local economy
Re-skilling
Smarter Europe
Talent management
Aveiro promotes remote education resources

Aveiro promotes remote education resources

Education is one of Aveiro STEAM City’s implementation axis and it is integrated in a wider strategy to stimulate digital transformation within the ci...

AVEIRO STEAM CITY - Urban Network for Upgrading STEAM Skills and Increasing Jobs Added-Value through Digital Transformation in a new economic context

Jobs and skills in the local economy

Aveiro - Portugal

Aveiro STEAM City assets: Education equipment in response to Covid-19

Aveiro STEAM City assets: Education equipment in response to Covid-19

The numbers are unprecedented and subsequent implications are extraordinary. As the COVID-19 pandemic has spread across the globe, worldwide countries...

AVEIRO STEAM CITY - Urban Network for Upgrading STEAM Skills and Increasing Jobs Added-Value through Digital Transformation in a new economic context

Jobs and skills in the local economy

Aveiro - Portugal

Aveiro Tech City Bootcamps

Coding skills for non-geeks only! A smart strategy to train human resources and retain talents in the Aveiro Region - Zoom-in

Aveiro Tech City Bootcamp is an intensive training program, dedicated to unemployed, students or employed professionals looking for new career opportu...

AVEIRO STEAM CITY - Urban Network for Upgrading STEAM Skills and Increasing Jobs Added-Value through Digital Transformation in a new economic context

Jobs and skills in the local economy

Aveiro - Portugal

Digital transition
Digitalisation
Education
Jobs and skills in the local economy
Talent management
Aveiro Steam City Journal: a new technological revolution in the city

Aveiro Steam City Journal: a new technological revolution in the city

Lucia Scopelliti, UIA Experts for the Aveiro STEAM city project, in this first edition of the Journal analyses how the project represents a huge chanc...

AVEIRO STEAM CITY - Urban Network for Upgrading STEAM Skills and Increasing Jobs Added-Value through Digital Transformation in a new economic context

Jobs and skills in the local economy

Aveiro - Portugal

Aveiro Urban Challenges and Aveiro 5G Challenges

Aveiro Urban Challenges and Aveiro 5G Challenges

Aveiro Urban Challenges and Aveiro 5G Challenges where presented to the community in October 2019, during the Techdays event. The City of Aveiro chall...

AVEIRO STEAM CITY - Urban Network for Upgrading STEAM Skills and Increasing Jobs Added-Value through Digital Transformation in a new economic context

Jobs and skills in the local economy

Aveiro - Portugal

Tech Labs at Schools

Tech Labs at Schools

Within the project Aveiro STEAM City and local STEAM education program, on February 5th the first Tech Lab was publicly presented at Escola EB1 de Sar...

AVEIRO STEAM CITY - Urban Network for Upgrading STEAM Skills and Increasing Jobs Added-Value through Digital Transformation in a new economic context

Jobs and skills in the local economy

Aveiro - Portugal

Aveiro Criatech Artistic Residences

Aveiro Criatech Artistic Residences

One of the main goals of Aveiro STEAM City project is to educate and qualify resources on STEAM competences (Science, Technology, Engineering, Arts an...

AVEIRO STEAM CITY - Urban Network for Upgrading STEAM Skills and Increasing Jobs Added-Value through Digital Transformation in a new economic context

Jobs and skills in the local economy

Aveiro - Portugal

Remarks from the study visit of Aveiro Steam City to Milano smart and sharing city

THE SECOND WAVE OF SMART CITIES: learning from the experience of a “SMART CITIES LIGHTHOUSE” PROJECT through a study visit in Milan

“The overall evidence suggests that we do not lack technologies, nor the data captured by technologies, but that the bigger challenge lies in governan...

AVEIRO STEAM CITY - Urban Network for Upgrading STEAM Skills and Increasing Jobs Added-Value through Digital Transformation in a new economic context

Jobs and skills in the local economy

Aveiro - Portugal

Aveiro Steam City project 1st challenges edition

Promoting Aveiro Steam City project and its challenges 1st edition

Aveiro intends to establishes itself as one of the first 5g trial cities in Portugal and Europe. Within this scope Aveiro 5G Challenges will award new...

AVEIRO STEAM CITY - Urban Network for Upgrading STEAM Skills and Increasing Jobs Added-Value through Digital Transformation in a new economic context

Jobs and skills in the local economy

Aveiro - Portugal

Aveiro STEAM City Energy Use Case – Electric “Moliceiros”

Aveiro STEAM City Energy Use Case – Electric “Moliceiros”

Within the project Aveiro STEAM City, the City of Aveiro is leading the Energy use case, planning to change the combustion engines of the traditional ...

AVEIRO STEAM CITY - Urban Network for Upgrading STEAM Skills and Increasing Jobs Added-Value through Digital Transformation in a new economic context

Jobs and skills in the local economy

Aveiro - Portugal

AVEIRO Steam City emergency drill using 5G communications

Aveiro STEAM City, 5G network just around the corner

On 11 September, Altice Labs, the telco partner of Aveiro STEAM city has conducted an emergency drill using 5G communications to support the SOS teams...

AVEIRO STEAM CITY - Urban Network for Upgrading STEAM Skills and Increasing Jobs Added-Value through Digital Transformation in a new economic context

Jobs and skills in the local economy

Aveiro - Portugal

Aveiro Steam City – Busy June | Visit from the Portuguese Government and Benchmarking Visit to Dublin

Visit of the Portuguese Government to Aveiro Steam City

As the first Portuguese project approved under the Urban Innovative Actions Initiative, Aveiro STEAM City has been in the spotlight. ...

AVEIRO STEAM CITY - Urban Network for Upgrading STEAM Skills and Increasing Jobs Added-Value through Digital Transformation in a new economic context

Jobs and skills in the local economy

Aveiro - Portugal

Smart cities summit

AVEIRO Steam City at the Portugal Smart Cities Summit

Aveiro STEAM City project attended the Portugal Smart Cities Summit, between 21st and 23rd of May in Lisbon. The event is the biggest conference and e...

AVEIRO STEAM CITY - Urban Network for Upgrading STEAM Skills and Increasing Jobs Added-Value through Digital Transformation in a new economic context

Jobs and skills in the local economy

Aveiro - Portugal

Aveito Steam City kick off

Aveiro Steam City kicking off!

On 08 March, The City of Aveiro organised the kick-off event of the project Aveiro Steam City. During the event, held at “Teatro Aveirense”, the City ...

AVEIRO STEAM CITY - Urban Network for Upgrading STEAM Skills and Increasing Jobs Added-Value through Digital Transformation in a new economic context

Jobs and skills in the local economy

Aveiro - Portugal