Expert article
Edit 09 May 2022
by Eddy Adams

Mapping the UIA innovation challenges with the Wish-Mi stakeholders

Wish-Mi article #4
Mapping the UIA innovation challenges with the Wish-Mi stakeholders

Working as the UIA expert for the Milano Wish-mi project for almost two years without meeting any of the team face to face has been one of my strangest career experiences. In more normal times, I would have visited the project every six months and by now would have built a strong connection not only with the city authority, but also with all of the partners round the table. 

But these have not been normal times, as life has thrown us all a curve ball in the shape of the pandemic. As a result, last week I had the chance - finally - to visit the city and see for myself what’s happening there with the project. In the end, the timing was quite opportune as two of the key planks of the wish-mi adventure - the physical hubs and the digital platform - will soon go live. That means the next six months is a defining moment for this project, and for Milan’s ambitious plans to transform its relationship and service delivery to children, young people and their families.

To help provide a snapshot of the project’s current position, we conducted an interactive stakeholder session focused on the seven UIA innovation challenges:

  • Leadership
  • Public procurement
  • Cross-departmental working
  • The participative approach for co-implementation
  • Monitoring and evaluation
  • Communication with target beneficiaries and users
  • Upscaling
     
    7 UIA innovation challenges activity
    Work in progress - Wish-MI stakeholders' analysis of the UIA innovation challenges

Although we had conducted a similar exercise online with MIRO during the project’s early days, it felt completely different this time. This was not just because the project has moved on since then, but also because the collaborative dynamic was very different when we were together in the same room, piggy backing on one another’s comments.

Everyone played an active part as we scored ourselves against each of the domains, creating patterns that illustrated the areas of consensus and those where partner views varied. This threw up some surprises for me. For example, although there have been challenges with the public procurement system, most partners scored this quite highly. Unpacking their scores,  they explained that’s because they have quite low expectations and although it has been frustrating, they have experienced much worse. This triggered a lively exchange on where Wish-mi partners should focus their energies to increase the prospects of sustainable systemic change. 

Other UIA challenges produced a different pattern of responses, including ‘communication with beneficiaries’ and ‘participation’ which were linked together and where partners disagreed about where we are and, crucially, what needs to be done. As the public elements of the project go live in the coming months, the quality of the project’s relationships on the ground will be key determinants of its success. At the same time, effective communication channels between stakeholders- as well as with project beneficiaries - will be key to building and maintaining trusted connections. 

Ahead of the visit, not knowing the stakeholders, I had not been sure of the dynamics within the partnership. So I felt privileged to hear these sometimes heated exchanges and to see that they were being dealt with in an open and constructive way. For me, that’s the sign of a resilient group where individuals feel comfortable discussing sensitive and challenging issues. It’s also an indication that partners feel sufficiently committed to the project - something that’s much harder to gauge from a distance. 

Recently, there has been some discussion amongst UIA experts about the value of these seven innovation challenges. But on balance I would say that they provide a useful starting point as a framework.  Yes, they are ‘off the shelf’ and quite top down, but there is scope to customise them as the Wishmi partners did by adding an eighth dimension - the working relationship between the public, private and NGO sectors. In this way, we have a framework that is consistent across all UIA projects, whilst also acknowledging distinct local features. We’ll have the chance to revisit these challenges  when we come together next in the autumn. 

In the meantime, we will continue with our online exchanges, knowing that the future is hybrid as we explore the right balance between online and face to face collaboration. But as I sat with partners round a table last Wednesday night eating pizza, enjoying a beer and talking off the record about the project, I was forcefully struck by the missed connections in these two years and the importance of being there, in real life, if we really want to understand and support the deeper innovation process. 
 

Share

Other news from this project

Image from one of the WISH-MI murals

WISH-MI Final Journal

WISH MI - Wellbeing Integrated System of Milan

Urban poverty

Milan - Italy

Urban poverty
La Fille Bertha- image courtesy of Tommaso Berra at Collateral

Harnessing art to enable youth participation: the WISH-MI experience

Podcast with Action Aid...

WISH MI - Wellbeing Integrated System of Milan

Urban poverty

Milan - Italy

Urban poverty
La Fille Bertha- image courtesy of Tommaso Berra at Collateral

WISH-MI Journal #3

This is the third WISH-MI journal and the first that has been produced since the full implementation of the project. ...

WISH MI - Wellbeing Integrated System of Milan

Urban poverty

Milan - Italy

Urban poverty
Giardino Felice

Giornata del Gioco: World Play Day as a launchpad for the WISH-MI missions

The City of Milan is opening new avenues in its drive to improve youth well-being in the city. To coincide with World Play Day, WISH-MI has launched a...

WISH MI - Wellbeing Integrated System of Milan

Urban poverty

Milan - Italy

Urban poverty
Milano youth co-design

Stimulating design innovation at the local level

WISH-MI aims to improve levels of youth wellbeing in the city of Milan. Improving the quality of, and access to, available services, is an important p...

WISH MI - Wellbeing Integrated System of Milan

Urban poverty

Milan - Italy

Urban poverty

Going Digital: The WISH-MI online platform gets the green light

The City of Milan has launched a digital platform to offer wellbeing services to its young people and families. The platform is now operational, comp...

WISH MI - Wellbeing Integrated System of Milan

Urban poverty

Milan - Italy

Urban poverty
Milano Wish-Mi hubs article

Wish-Mi hubs ready to hit the ground

Wish-Mi is an ambitious wellbeing strategy for the young people of Milan. The model comprises a digital hub, enabling access to services, combined wit...

WISH MI - Wellbeing Integrated System of Milan

Urban poverty

Milan - Italy

Urban poverty
WISH-MI Journal #2

Preparing to land: WISH-MI about to go live

The second WISH-MI journal presents the state of play as the project prepares to go live. It draws upon material gathered during the expert visit to M...

WISH MI - Wellbeing Integrated System of Milan

Urban poverty

Milan - Italy

Urban poverty
WISH-MI article

Building youth wellbeing through community hubs

A sneak peek of the WISH-MI hubs. City of Milan Director, Sabina Banfi. Shares her thoughts on the project’s new youth spaces with UIA Expert Eddy Ada...

WISH MI - Wellbeing Integrated System of Milan

Urban poverty

Milan - Italy

Urban poverty
WISH-MI

Money talks: How Milan and other UIA cities are stimulating behaviour change using financial proxies.

Milan is one of a number of UIA cities exploring innovative financial tools to nudge behaviours. This article explores the Milan vouchers model, and t...

WISH MI - Wellbeing Integrated System of Milan

Urban poverty

Milan - Italy

Urban poverty
WISH-MI ZOOM-IN 1

Co-designing services with young people. WISH-MI ZOOM-IN

This slide deck shares the content and learnings from the WISH-MI youth co-design webinar held on 9th June 2021. ...

WISH MI - Wellbeing Integrated System of Milan

Urban poverty

Milan - Italy

Urban poverty
WISH-MI Journal 1

WISH-MI Journal 1

Milan is a city of 1.4 million people, 230,000 of whom are minors. It has a wide and growing rate of inequality, with 30% of its population either in ...

WISH MI - Wellbeing Integrated System of Milan

Urban poverty

Milan - Italy

Urban poverty
Politecnico di Milano Visual Identity Study

WISH-MI: Resetting the wellbeing dial for Milan’s youth

Like many cities, Milan faces the challenge of widening inequalities. This risk particularly affect the city's most vulnerable young people. The UIA W...

WISH MI - Wellbeing Integrated System of Milan

Urban poverty

Milan - Italy

Urban poverty